Superstore
AUCTIONS
Autostock
Ryan Newman has more top-fives (four) in 2009 than Dale Earnhardt Jr. has top-10s (three).

Head2Head: The career moves of Junior, Newman

By NASCAR.COM
June 5, 2009
05:15 PM EDT
Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
type size: + -

There was a time when their best appeared to still be ahead of them, given the success they had early in their careers. In 2005, however, things began to change.

Dale Earnhardt Jr. won 14 races before his 30th birthday. From 2000-04 he won at least two races every year culminating with six wins in '04. He's won only three races since.

Dale Earnhardt Jr. and Ryan Newman
Earnhardt and Newman

Ryan Newman burst onto the scene in just his second full season with eight victories in '03. He won twice more the following year but has just two more wins since the start of '05.

The past two years have seen each driver make a bold career change; Junior having left his father's organization for Hendrick Motorsports last year and Newman in his first season with Stewart-Haas Racing after spending his entire career with Penske Racing.

While Year 2 has been a struggle for Earnhardt, resulting in the removal of cousin Tony Eury Jr. as crew chief last week, Newman is fifth in points with a first-year organization.

So which driver made the better career move? Jason Schoellen and Jarrod Breeze debate. Read both sides and then weigh in with your takeexternal link. And don't forget to vote on whose argument you agree with the most.

Which driver made the better career move?

DALE EARNHARDT JR. RYAN NEWMAN

When Dale Earnhardt Jr. announced he was leaving DEI, he vowed to join an organization that offered him his best chance to win a championship. He couldn't have done any better than choosing the sport's premier team -- one that offers comfort, stability and resources he couldn't get anywhere else.

Earnhardt despised driving for his stepmother -- the battles became bitter through the years. Now, he's wheeling cars for a "father figure." Your job is a lot more enjoyable when you respect your boss. Sure, the pressure to win is there ... but Junior will learn to "tame" it, much like champions Jeff Gordon and Jimmie Johnson.

Things have been in flux at Earnhardt's former team since he left. It has had problems getting sponsorship dollars to the demise of Aric Almirola and Regan Smith. Paul Menard left and Martin Truex Jr. is rumored to be gone next season. This potentially leaves just Juan Montoya -- a holdover from this year's merger. While Earnhardt Ganassi Racing resembles a sinking ship, Dale Jr. is sailing on the S.S. Hendrick.

Earnhardt is in the best equipment in the business and is flanked by three of the sport's finest drivers. Hendrick showed its depth in the personnel department at Dover, subbing in Lance McGrew as interim crew chief with positive results.

Ryan Newman has come on strong of late, but Penske Racing as a whole also has improved. Junior, meanwhile, benefitted more -- especially long-term -- with his career-saving move to Hendrick because while his former team flounders, Earnhardt is with a team that can help him flourish like never before.

Jason Schoellen, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

Ryan Newman needed to get the heck out of a Dodge. Since Newman made the second of his consecutive Chase appearances in 2005, Dodge has had just two drivers make NASCAR's playoffs -- Kasey Kahne in '06 and Kurt Busch in '07.

In '09, Busch again carries the Dodge banner alone in the top 12 with Kahne the only other driver in sniffing distance of the Chase cutoff. Newman, meanwhile, is flourishing after a slow start in which bad luck was more a culprit than anything else.

Beginning at Bristol, Newman has posted seven top-10s in nine races. His eighth-place finish at Dover ended a run of four consecutive top-fives, but he's the only driver with a current five-race top-10 streak.

In contrast to his previous three years at Penske in which he never finished higher than 13th in points, Newman already has surpassed his top-five totals from '06 and '08 (two each), matched his top-10 total from '06 and is just one behind his '08 number of eight.

It should be noted that Dale Earnhardt Jr. got off to a good start in his first year at Hendrick -- through the first 18 races in '08, Junior ended a long winless streak, posted seven top-fives, 12 top-10s and finished worse than 15th just three times -- but has floundered since. At Hendrick Motorsports, there are no excuses.

For Newman, the danger of driving for a first-year team -- yeah, Stewart-Haas was created out of the former Haas CNC Racing but in reality the only similarity is the name Haas -- was offset by the public perception of low expections. Well, the former isn't a concern and the latter hasn't materialized.

Jarrod Breeze, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

The End

Share Article Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
  • MySpace
  • Facebook
  • Digg
 
POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Poll

Whose argument do you agree with the most?
Jason Schoellen
Jarrod Breeze
view results

Career Cup Results

Dale Earnhardt Jr.
Year No. W T-5 T-10 Avg. Fin. Points
1999 5 0 0 1 21.4 48
2000 34 2 3 5 20.9 16
2001 36 3 9 15 15.2 8
2002 36 2 11 16 17.1 11
2003 36 2 13 21 12.7 3
2004 36 6 16 21 12.1 5
2005 36 1 7 13 20.5 19
2006 36 1 10 17 13.5 5
2007 36 0 7 12 18.6 16
2008 36 1 10 16 14.1 12
2009 13 0 1 3 20.6 18

Ryan Newman
Year No. W T-5 T-10 Avg. Fin. Points
2000 1 0 0 0 41.0 70
2001 7 0 2 2 24.7 49
2002 36 1 14 22 14.5 6
2003 36 8 17 22 13.9 6
2004 36 2 11 14 16.5 7
2005 36 1 8 16 15.3 6
2006 36 0 2 7 20.6 18
2007 36 0 7 15 18.6 13
2008 36 1 2 8 20.3 17
2009 13 0 4 7 13.5 5

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2009 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Turner Entertainment Digital Network NASCAR.COM is part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Digital Network.