FOLLOW ON: Twitter Facebook RSS
Superstore
AUCTIONS
Getty Images
Joey Logano and Scott Speed each come into the Cup Series amid a lot of fanfare.

As rookies go, which way will Logano and Speed go?

By Jarrod Breeze, NASCAR.COM
February 28, 2009
12:11 PM EST
type size: + -

Joey Logano finished 26th last week at Fontana, his best result in five races at the Sprint Cup level. Scott Speed has made seven starts with his best showing a 16th-place finish in last year's season finale at Homestead. Neither driver has finished better than 30th in any other race.

The two constitute the 2009 rookie class, the smallest since '05 and just the third two-driver class this decade. And while there remains a long way to go and both drivers are high in talent and celebrity, the dearth of recent rookie success begs the question: Where have all the good young drivers gone?

Getty Images

Rough start

It's been a rather inauspicious beginning to the season for Joey Logano and Scott Speed.

The reality is that most already are here, dating to the highly successful 2006 bumper crop that has produced six Chase appearances. Of the six drivers in that class, five have full-time rides in '09:

Denny Hamlin became the first rookie to make the Chase and finished third in points that year. He has made the Chase in each of his three full seasons.
Clint Bowyer is coming off back-to-back Chase appearances in which he finished in the top five in points.
Martin Truex Jr. made the Chase in '07 and became the face of DEI in 2008 after Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s departure.
Reed Sorenson was the youngest of the group at age 20 and this year finds himself in the No. 43 Dodge of Richard Petty Motorsports.
David Stremme is back this year after making just one start in '08, replacing 2002 rookie of the year Ryan Newman in the No. 12 Dodge of Penske Racing.

Sorenson is one of five current full-time drivers to have debuted since 2004 who are still 25 years old or younger: Brian Vickers (25), Kyle Busch (24), David Ragan (23), Sorenson (23) and Logano (19).

Ragan is part of the 2007 class that has flashed potential but not as yet made any significant waves. Ragan, while still winless, has since made the biggest gains, increasing his top-five total by four and top-10s by 11 in '08.

Juan Montoya was the 2007 rookie of the year with one win, three top-fives and six top-10s. But he regressed in '08 with two top-fives and three top-10s. Paul Menard, David Reutimann and A.J. Allmendinger have combined for two top-fives and nine top-10s in their careers.

You have to go back to 1998 when the rookie of the year didn't have double digits in top-10s. But you have to go back even farther to find a rookie class that didn't produce one single top-10, the distinction the 2008 class carries alone.

Regan Smith is the only rookie of the year not to post a top-10 finish since 1957, the first year NASCAR began recognizing rookies. Of course, Smith thought he had a win this past October at Talladega, but NASCAR claimed he made the winning pass below the yellow line. The penalty not only cost Smith a win, but his first top-10. He was dropped to the end of the lead line, which was 18th.

With the DEI-Ganassi merger, Smith found himself without a ride and although he landed with Furniture Row Racing, the team is running only a partial schedule. But of last year's five-driver class, only Sam Hornish Jr. has a full ride in '09. None of the other three drivers -- Patrick Carpentier, Michael McDowell and Dario Franchitti -- finished the season.

To that end, it's been 58 races since a rookie won a race in the Cup Series, 48 races since one posted a top-five and 38 races since the last top-10.

Page 1
Page 2

In 2009, only two drivers are eligible to end those streaks. But the past two two-driver rookie classes have done the sport proud. In 2005, rookie of the year Busch became the youngest (20) winner in Cup history. And in 2002, although he finished second to Newman, another up-and-coming driver won three times, the most of any rookie since. His name? Jimmie Johnson.

More
Speed making inroads in first full season in Cup
Gibbs dials down pressure for wunderkind Logano

Rookie Classes

2008
    2008         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Regan Smith 34 0 0 0   1 0 0 0   42 0 0 0
2. Sam Hornish Jr. 34 0 0 0   2 0 0 0   38 0 0 0
3. Patrick Carpentier 24 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   27 0 0 0
4. Michael McDowell 20 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   20 0 0 0
5. Dario Franchitti 10 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   10 0 0 0

2007
    2007         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Juan Montoya 36 1 3 6   2 0 0 0   75 1 5 9
2. David Ragan 36 0 2 3   2 0 0 1   76 0 8 18
3. Paul Menard 30 0 0 0   2 0 0 0   77 0 1 2
4. David Reutimann 26 0 0 0   2 0 0 0   65 0 0 4
5. A.J. Allmendinger 17 0 0 0   2 0 1 1   46 0 1 3

2006
    2006         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Denny Hamlin 36 2 8 20   2 0 0 1   117 4 32 60
2. Clint Bowyer 36 0 4 11   2 0 1 1   111 2 17 46
3. Martin Truex Jr. 36 0 2 5   2 0 0 0   119 1 12 31
4. Reed Sorenson 36 0 1 5   2 0 0 1   111 0 5 14
5. J.J. Yeley 36 0 0 3   0 0 0 0   95 0 2 7
6. David Stremme 34 0 0 0   2 0 0 0   77 0 0 3

2005
    2005         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Kyle Busch 36 2 9 13   2 0 1 1   152 12 48 73
2. Travis Kvapil 36 0 0 2   2 0 0 0   108 0 0 6

2004
    2004         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Kasey Kahne 36 0 13 14   2 0 0 0   182 9 35 63
2. Brendan Gaughan 36 0 1 4   0 0 0 0   36 0 1 4
3. Brian Vickers 36 0 0 4   2 0 0 1   119 1 12 31
4. Scott Wimmer 35 0 1 2   0 0 0 0   106 0 1 3
5. Scott Riggs 35 0 1 2   2 0 0 0   169 0 4 16
6. Johnny Sauter 16 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   76 0 1 3

2003
    2003         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Jamie McMurray 36 0 5 13   2 0 0 0   224 2 29 75
2. Greg Biffle 35 1 3 6   2 0 1 1   224 14 48 79
3. Tony Raines 35 0 0 1   0 0 0 0   128 0 0 3
4. Casey Mears 36 0 0 0   2 0 0 0   218 1 12 42
5. Jack Sprague 18 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   24 0 0 0
6. Larry Foyt 20 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   23 0 0 0

2002
    2002         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Ryan Newman 36 1 14 22   2 0 0 0   262 13 63 106
2. Jimmie Johnson 36 3 6 21   2 0 0 1   257 40 101 157

2001
    2001         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Kevin Harvick 35 2 6 16   2 0 1 1   288 11 57 121
2. Kurt Busch 35 0 3 6   2 0 1 2   294 18 62 117
3. Casey Atwood 35 0 1 3   0 0 0 1   75 0 1 4
4. Jason Leffler 30 0 0 1   0 0 0 0   65 0 0 1
5. Ron Hornaday 32 0 0 1   0 0 0 0   45 0 0 1

2000
    2000         2009         Career      
POS. DRIVER RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10   RACES W T-5 T-10
1. Matt Kenseth 34 1 4 11   2 2 2 2   330 18 90 164
2. Dale Earnhardt Jr. 34 2 3 5   2 0 0 0   329 18 86 137
3. Dave Blaney 33 0 0 2   1 0 0 0   304 0 3 27
4. Scott Pruett 28 0 0 1   0 0 0 0   40 0 3 6
5. Stacy Compton 27 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   88 0 0 1
6. Mike Bliss 25 0 0 1   0 0 0 0   82 0 1 5
7. Ed Berrier 10 0 0 0   0 0 0 0   10 0 0 0

The End

POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Columnists

Sprint Cup Series

Driver Standings
Pos. +/- Driver Points Behind
1. -- Matt Kenseth 385 Leader
2. +10 Jeff Gordon 304 -81
3. +8 Kurt Busch 294 -91
4. +3 Tony Stewart 294 -91
5. +15 Greg Biffle 268 -117
6. -2 Clint Bowyer 266 -119
7. +1 Michael Waltrip 264 -121
8. -2 David Ragan 262 -123
9. +9 Carl Edwards 260 -125
10. +4 Juan Montoya 256 -129
11. -6 Elliott Sadler 248 -137
12. +1 David Reutimann 248 -137
What's Hot in NASCAR Search
Top Searches Updated Twice Daily by Ask.com
More Searches

Most Popular

Photo Gallery

Driver of the Week Eric McClure

ViewArchive

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2012 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
NASCAR.COM is part of Turner - SI Digital, part of the Turner Sports & Entertainment Digital Network.