FOLLOW ON: Twitter Facebook RSS
Superstore
AUCTIONS
One Menz Opinion
Getty Images
Don't put too much stock into Tuesday's meeting -- NASCAR has done this before.

Thoughts during the rain delay for the Coca-Cola 600

Long's punishment too much; Bruton should stop talking

By Joe Menzer, NASCAR.COM
May 25, 2009
04:42 PM EDT
type size: + -

CONCORD, N.C. -- There are a few odds and ends to be dumped like rain from the notebook and the mind as Day 2 of the 50th running of the Coca-Cola 600 at Lowe's Motor Speedway rolled on Monday.

So even before reaching the checkered flag, here we go while dodging the latest raindrops and hoping Day 2 doesn't turn into Day 3.

Meeting of the minds

On Tuesday NASCAR will hold a mandatory meeting with owners and drivers at its Research and Development Center a few miles from Lowe's Motor Speedway. Chairman Brian France said everything will be on the table to be discussed in a "town-hall meeting" type of setting.

Listen, this isn't the first time, nor will it be the last, that NASCAR holds this kind of meeting with owners and drivers during a season. They held one last June during a race weekend at Michigan, ostensibly to discuss making sure fans were treated with tender care -- but also in what appeared to be an attempt to do damage control in the wake of a $225 million racial and sexual discrimination lawsuit filed by a former female NASCAR official (since settled out of court). So let's not make too much of this latest meeting of the minds.

It's obvious, though, that the drivers want some questions answered about the governing body's tougher substance abuse policy that has been so much (maybe too much) in the news since the indefinite suspension of driver Jeremy Mayfield under a cloud of controversy. And they should get them. One thing that makes this sport different from others -- and arguably might give competitors the right to know what fellow competitors have tested positive for -- is that they operate 3,400-pound stock cars at high speeds in the same arena. That's quite a bit different than, say, if they were on a football or baseball field.

But the drug policy will not be the only topic covered Tuesday at the R&D Center, nor should it be. There are many issues that need to be addressed -- including ways to improve attendance and television ratings in a declining economy, as well as ways to deal with disappearing sponsorship dollars and make the "new car," which isn't so new anymore, as racy as it is safe.

Page 1
Page 2

Crime vs. punishment

By now everyone has heard of and chewed on the fact that NASCAR laid down a sledgehammer on driver-owner Carl Long, whose car for the Sprint Showdown was ruled to have an engine that measured roughly one-one thousandth of an inch bigger than is allowed.

The punishment handed down to a team on a shoestring budget by NASCAR for this infraction: a 12-week suspension from the track for Long, who works for other teams when he's not attempting to make a race himself and therefore will take a double-financial hit, and a record $200,000 fine that threatens to put his small operation out of business altogether. Fellow driver Jeff Burton said he understands where NASCAR was coming from when it swung the sledgehammer.

Autostock

If you never make people regret doing the wrong thing, they'll never do the right thing. So I'm in favor of big penalties because I think it makes it where people don't want to mess around.

-- JEFF BURTON

"One of the things that keep people honest is the fact that a car that probably didn't have a chance to win the race was torn down and that their engine was torn down," Burton said. "What that means to a team that doesn't feel like they might have a chance to win but is thinking maybe they can cheat and finish 18th, it tells them don't do that.

"We have seen over the years an escalation in penalties, an escalation in [fine] money -- and big engines are something that NASCAR seems to have no tolerance for. That's a really, really big penalty -- especially for Carl and the financial situation they're in. But you know, tall fences make great neighbors and big rules make people not cheat.

"If you never make people regret doing the wrong thing, they'll never do the right thing. So I'm in favor of big penalties because I think it makes it where people don't want to mess around."

Problem is, Long said in a statement that he bought the engine from a reputable source -- another team that frequently supplies his engines -- and that the engine was so worn out there is no way he gained any kind of advantage anyway. In this case, the punishment clearly does not fit the crime and Long should win his appeal to have the fine and suspension dramatically reduced. If he doesn't, that will be a greater injustice than his seemingly inadvertent attempt to run a marginally bigger engine.

'Nuff said

In this week's version of he said, she said, 'Nuff said ... Bruton Smith and Humpy Wheeler were firing potshots at each other over the weekend.

Humpy was miffed that he wasn't invited to LMS for the festivities surrounding the 50th running of the Coca-Cola 600, which he presided over so magnificently for so many years. Bruton was miffed that Humpy was miffed, saying he wasn't aware that he had to send out invitations to anybody and that Wheeler, the former LMS president, had a NASCAR hard card that can get him into any race Wheeler wants.

Smith, who owns the track Wheeler ran for a quarter-century, didn't stop there, either. He went on to -- again -- stress his point that Wheeler retired of his own volition last year. He said Wheeler came into his office and more or less demanded a $5 million retirement gift, which isn't quite the way Wheeler tells the story.

To be honest, the media has tended to side with Wheeler on this one because, well, he's been so much nicer and easier to deal with over the years. Smith likes to entertain the media on his own terms, which he does with great fanfare four or five times a year. But he just isn't as believable as Humpy, and has a track record of bullying people and even entire communities (remember his threat to close down LMS and move it if city and county officials didn't bow to his demands regarding a certain drag strip he wanted built next to the Concord track?).

The bottom line is that these are two very rich men squabbling over money and their legacies in the history of LMS, both of which are secure and can only be damaged by further petty debates. 'Nuff said on the subject that is now officially more than a year old but is beginning to seem much older.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

Joe Menzer is the author of "The Great American Gamble: How the 1979 Daytona 500 Gave Birth to a NASCAR Nation." Click here to purchase.

The End

Also

POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Columnists

Photo Gallery

Driver of the Week Eric McClure

ViewArchive

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2012 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
NASCAR.COM is part of Turner - SI Digital, part of the Turner Sports & Entertainment Digital Network.