Superstore
AUCTIONS
Inside Line - David Caraviello
Autostock
Kyle Busch and Kasey Kahne are proof the new car is working the way it is supposed to.

Hate the new car? Too bad. Daytona showed us why

Earnhardt, Davis crashes the reason change is needed

By David Caraviello, NASCAR.COM
July 8, 2009
10:26 AM EDT
Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
type size: + -

For anyone still undecided about the need for a version of the new car in the Nationwide Series, Kerry Earnhardt's accident Friday night at Daytona International Speedway should have sealed it. It took the son of seven-time champion Dale Earnhardt 30 slow, painful seconds to extricate himself from his crumpled and smoldering race car, something he was able to do only after pulling off his helmet. Earnhardt was in that fume-filled cockpit long enough that he was treated for smoke inhalation at the track's care center.

It wasn't the evening's only hairy escape. Kertus Davis tumbled out of his race car, helmet and all, after the vehicle burst into flames following an accident. Thankfully, neither driver was hurt. But episodes like those underscore the fact that, despite misguided grousing about competition, the Nationwide tour needs its own "new car" complete with all the safety enhancements of the Cup Series model, among them a wider, taller driver compartment that's easier to scramble out of when the vehicle is consumed by fumes or flames.

Although NASCAR is still negotiating with teams about an optimum schedule, there's already talk that this revised Nationwide vehicle could be rolled out on restrictor-plate tracks and road courses as early as next year, with full implementation following in 2011. Of course, cost is an issue on the Nationwide tour even more so than on the Cup circuit, and the recessed economy is certainly a factor to be overcome. An expensive phase-in of an expensive new car could easily push those organizations already facing sponsorship issues -- and there are plenty of those in the Nationwide garage -- to the brink. Managing the cost-effectiveness of this vehicle, which earned good reviews during its inaugural test at Richmond late last year, will be paramount. But eventually, it has to become a reality. Drivers on the Nationwide circuit are every bit as deserving of improved safety features as their higher-profile brethren on the Cup tour.

Page 1
Page 2

But oh, you can just hear the howls coming from the grandstand, the wailing and gnashing of teeth from race fans that are already weary of the growing pains of the new Cup car, and are unlikely to warmly embrace another one on the Nationwide tour. Oh, it's going to be harder to drive. Oh, it's going to interfere with competition. Probably, and maybe. But you're going to have to deal with it, because you can't have it both ways. You can't demand events like we saw this past weekend in Daytona -- races that were almost gladiatorial in their quality, and exist solely for the viewing pleasure (and we use that word very loosely) of spectators -- and not expect drivers to be girded for automotive combat by every modern safety device.

It feels as if fans expect every driver to emerge from every violent crash unscathed these days, casually blind to the fact that even amid so many safety advances, auto racing can never, ever be truly made 100 percent safe.

And that's what this new car is, a safety device, one that's done it's job so well that people have grown somewhat complacent with the sight of Michael McDowell walking away at Texas, Carl Edwards walking away at Talladega, Jeff Gordon walking away at Las Vegas, and other drivers walking away from other crashes that would have sent them to the hospital a decade ago. In the aftermath of something as violent as the accident on the final lap of the Cup race Saturday night at Daytona, there should be an overwhelming sense of relief that Kyle Busch -- and Kasey Kahne, for that matter -- escaped the melee unscathed. There's none of that. Instead, there's a blame game, excessive finger-pointing over who was at fault for the wreck. The fact that Busch and Kahne walked away is almost taken for granted. It feels as if fans expect every driver to emerge from every violent crash unscathed these days, casually blind to the fact that even amid so many safety advances, auto racing can never, ever be truly made 100 percent safe.

Amid all this, people have the gall to rip the new car, to say it's ruined the sport, to question whether the Nationwide Series really needs it or not. Please. In some ways, the very architects of that new car were the people who bought tickets to places like Daytona and Talladega, who regaled in mechanical destruction, who fostered the creation of a modern Colosseum atmosphere at 200 mph. The new car is NASCAR's attempt at forging some kind of middle ground, of retaining the aspects of restrictor-plate racing that so many people find thrilling, and yet of providing maximum protection to drivers who just suck it up and try to get through it. Still, people hate it. They want the old car back, no matter how many drivers got hurt in it. It's as coldhearted as the idea of football fans getting angry because they can't see players' faces, and demanding that teams take the field without helmets.

So get used to the new car. Oh, you might curse its existence, you might threaten to swear off NASCAR and find another racing series, but crashes like the one that unfolded Saturday night show why it exists on the Cup tour. Fiery accidents like those that occurred Friday night show why it's needed on the Nationwide circuit. And the fact that Kyle Busch made a furious, recalcitrant trip to the infield care center -- rather than one on a stretcher -- showed once again that it works.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

The End

Share Article Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
  • MySpace
  • Facebook
  • Digg
 

Also

POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Columnists

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2009 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Turner Entertainment Digital Network NASCAR.COM is part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Digital Network.