![]()

With NASCAR's 60th season in the rear-view mirror -- and the ripple effect of Jimmie Johnson's third consecutive Cup Series championship still making its way across the landscape -- the debate is raging over the No. 48 team's place in history.
Regardless of the Chase system, the race results speak for themselves. It is those race results, broken into four-year intervals, which NASCAR.COM has examined and now presents with no preconceived notion of which driver is the "best" in regards to era, point system or rule changes (read: lucky dog passes).
Check the stats and then weigh in with your choice
for which Cup Series driver had the best four-year run.
| Years (Races) |
Starts | Wins | Top-5s | Top-10s | Avg. Finish | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2005-08 (144) |
16 tied | 144 | J.Johnson | 26 | J.Johnson | 61 | J.Johnson | 92 | J.Johnson | 10.910 |
| 2001-04 (144) |
13 tied | 144 | J.Gordon | 17 | J.Gordon | 62 | J.Gordon | 89 | J.Gordon | 12.333 |
| 1997-00 (133) |
11 tied | 133 | J.Gordon | 33 | D.Jarrett | 78 | D.Jarrett | 98 | D.Jarrett | 9.639 |
| 1993-96 (123) |
14 tied | 123 | R.Wallace | 25 | D.Earnhardt | 69 | D.Earnhardt | 86 | D.Earnhardt | 9.032 |
| 1989-92 (116) |
14 tied | 116 | D.Earnhardt | 19 | M.Martin | 54 | D.Earnhardt | 78 | M.Martin | 10.422 |
| 1985-88 (115) |
12 tied | 115 | B.Elliott | 25 | D.Earnhardt | 60 | D.Earnhardt | 82 | D.Earnhardt | 9.156 |
| 1981-84 (121) |
8 tied | 121 | D.Waltrip | 37 | D.Waltrip | 73 | D.Waltrip | 90 | B.Allison | 8.769 |
| 1977-80 (122) |
7 tied | 122 | C.Y'borough | 29 | C.Y'borough | 86 | C.Y'borough | 95 | C.Y'borough | 7.049 |
| 1973-76 (118) |
3 tied | 118 | R.Petty | 32 | R.Petty | 77 | R.Petty | 86 | D.Pearson | 8.225 |
| 1969-72 (181) |
J.Hylton | 176 | R.Petty | 57 | R.Petty | 121 | J.Hylton R.Petty |
138 | R.Petty | 6.024 |
| 1965-68 (202) |
W.Scott | 190 | R.Petty | 55 | R.Petty | 99 | R.Petty | 107 | D.Pearson | 7.333 |
| 1961-64 (222) |
N.Jarrett | 210 | R.Petty | 33 | R.Petty | 117 | N.Jarrett | 153 | J.Weatherly | 7.289 |
| 1957-60 (192) |
L.Petty | 172 | L.Petty | 27 | L.Petty | 96 | L.Petty | 141 | L.Petty | 7.157 |
| 1953-56 (175) |
L.Petty | 159 | H.Thomas | 32 | B.Baker | 94 | B.Baker | 126 | B.Baker | 6.962 |
| 1949-52 (181) |
L.Petty | 87 | T.Flock H.Thomas |
16 | T.Flock | 47 | L. Petty | 64 | L.Petty | 8.379 |