The 2026 NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series has officially wrapped. Thirty-three races, 5,623 laps, 459 lead changes, 15 different winners and one grand champion later, a campaign of ebbs and flows concluded at Homestead-Miami Speedway, with Justin Allgaier clinching his second title in three seasons.
After seeing how The Chase presented by Mobil 1 field stacked up before the postseason began, let's see how drivers fared for the final installment of the season, with NASCAR.com's John Crane re-ranking the top 12 Chase drivers and summarizing their respective campaigns.
RELATED: 2026 O'Reilly Auto Parts Series standings | 2027 O'Reilly Auto Parts Series schedule

Analysis: He was No. 1 in this installment for most of the season for a reason. Though he did not win a race during the nine-race Chase, steady points performances — an average of 42 points per contest — compounded into title No. 2. With the triumph, the 40-year-old Allgaier became the oldest O'Reilly champion since 41-year-old Tommy Ellis in 1988 and the 10th driver to win multiple O'Reilly championships. Can Allgaier become the first driver to win three O'Reilly titles? With a return to JR Motorsports on a multiyear deal in 2027, we will find out.

Analysis: Though the 2025 O'Reilly champion fell short of going back-to-back — and being the first to do so in the circuit since 2018-19 — the No. 2 Richard Childress Racing driver gave it the college try during The Chase, winning twice (Gateway, Phoenix) and finishing outside the top 20 only once (30th, Martinsville). Of Love's three full-time O'Reilly seasons, 2026 could arguably be categorized as the grittiest, overcoming rough patches and winless droughts en route to a P2 finish in the title standings. This experience will now carry over to the NASCAR Cup Series, with Love piloting Wood Brothers Racing's No. 21 entry in 2027.

Analysis: The breakout O'Reilly season finally arrived. After entering 2026 with 15 runner-ups and zero wins, Creed found Victory Lane three times, including twice in The Chase (Darlington, Bristol). Save for a Phoenix Raceway P32, Creed was nails during the postseason and, at times, looked like the championship was his to lose. Entering Homestead, Creed still had a mathematical shot before ultimately finishing fourth in the championship standings. The dam needed breaking in 2026 for Creed. Now it's about carrying that wave of momentum into next season, this time with Sam Hunt Racing.

Analysis: The 23-year-old Kvapil has plenty to be proud of. Alternating between three separate teams during the regular season was plenty of reason enough, but adding three race wins only makes it more impressive. Kvapil entered The Chase as the No. 2 seed, and after a clutch Martinsville Speedway victory on Halloween, entered Homestead with a championship chance. That momentum could mean all the difference in the future, and with a full-time slate in the No. 8 JR Motorsports Chevrolet in 2027, Kvapil can find comfort in start-to-finish continuity with one team.

Analysis: What if Day didn't wreck in the opening laps at Homestead? Entering the race only 23 points behind Allgaier, Day had a realistic path to factor into the championship equation. Whatever the case, Day's first full-time campaign was plenty glamorous, with four race victories (including back-to-back Chase wins at Las Vegas and Charlotte), 422 laps led and a 9.5 average start. Refining speed and cleaning up the DNFs (he had six in 2026) is next for the 20-year-old Day, who will return to the No. 17 Hendrick Motorsports camp in 2027.

Analysis: That's a way to finish a season. The No. 20 Joe Gibbs Racing driver tallied five straight top-10 finishes to conclude The Chase, capped off with a race victory at Homestead. Save for a handful of 30th-or-worse finishes (including a 36th-place DNF at Las Vegas during The Chase), Jones' campaign was marked by consistency, with a career-best 11.9 average finish and 20 top-10 results. Still, an eighth-place finish in the standings was a downtick from his fifth-place result in 2025. Returning to Joe Gibbs Racing in 2027, Jones will aim to turn that fortune around.

Analysis: I was critical of Smith in these ranking installments this season. He was always … fine. OK results, certainly. But battling at the front of the field for race wins? Lacking. He broke that mold at Talladega Superspeedway in The Chase, snapping a 53-race winless skid … a day removed from winning the NASCAR Craftsman Truck Series race there. With a seventh-place result in the standings after finishing 16th or better in all nine Chase races, Smith concluded his JR Motorsports chapter in style. Up next? A full-time transition to Tricon Garage in the Truck Series in 2027.

Analysis: My criticism in past installments regarding Mayer primarily revolved around excellent starts but less-than-excellent finishes. For context: Mayer finished outside the top 20 eight times during the regular season … despite starting those races inside the top 10. The Chase saw the No. 41 show more consistency in that aspect; in six of nine Chase contests, Mayer started inside the top 15 and finished in the top 10. With a career-best 283 laps led in 2026, the Wisconsin native will look to build on that next season when he returns to JR Motorsports as driver of the No. 1 Chevy.

Analysis: It was a career year for the 23-year-old Retzlaff, who made the postseason for the first time and additionally logged a career-high five top fives and 13 top 10s. A 14.2 average start and 13.2 average finish were career bests, and with only two DNFs across the season, it was a clean campaign. Returning to Viking Motorsports in 2027, Retzlaff will look to cross off the next big to-do: Find Victory Lane. Will it be done? To be determined. If it does, don't say it didn't sneak up on you.

Analysis: Year 2 as an O'Reilly full-timer was almost identical to Year 1: One win in both 2025 and 2026, seven top fives vs. five, 15 top 10s for both, two separate postseason appearances. In Joe Gibbs Racing equipment, Gray will remain a Chase contender, with the 21-year-old New Mexico native returning to the No. 54 team in 2027. The big question is breaking into the upper echelon of the field. The results in the aggregate are nice; now, it's about increasing the frequency of those results, especially in the race-winning department.

Analysis: Heading into this year's Chase, one could have argued Hill was second only to Allgaier in terms of experience in the O'Reilly Series. Yet, after four consecutive seasons of top-six finishes in the standings, Hill's 2026 postseason was a dud, with four finishes of 20th or worse and only one top five. Overall, his eight top fives, 15 top 10s and 177 laps led were career lows. Hill's O'Reilly tenure now comes to an end, with the Georgia native going full-time racing for Richard Childress Racing in the Cup Series in 2027.

Analysis: With that, Caruth's first full-time O'Reilly campaign is in the books, with the 24-year-old Georgia native splitting time between two race teams. Similarly to Kvapil, alternating between multiple race teams should be a victory in and of itself, and making The Chase with one of them (No. 88 JR Motorsports Chevrolet) only adds to that luster. What can be built upon going into 2027, with Caruth returning to JR Motorsports? Excellent qualifying during the postseason; Caruth started inside the top 13 in all nine Chase contests, with a 12.4 average start overall during the season.