Fred Rogers made a living out of being a nice guy. Put on a soft sweater, change into some comfortable shoes, sprinkle some food in the fish tank, say hello to Lady Elaine. Just try to get angry while you are watching “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood,” or the recent documentary on him, “Won’t You Be My Neighbor?” It’s impossible, you just can’t do it.
But what if Mr. Rogers were in the heat of a short-track battle at Martinsville Speedway? Would he still live by the Golden Rule? Or would the competitive juices start to flow and eventually boil over?
By no means is Martin Truex Jr. a Mr. Rogers clone, but Truex does have the reputation of being one of the nicest guys in the Monster Energy NASCAR Cup Series garage. Try to recall not seeing him with a smile beneath that beard of his. It’s pretty impossible to imagine.
However, now that Joey Logano pulled his bump-and-run move to win at Martinsville and Truex has hinted at revenge, is change in the air? Should there be no more Mr. Nice Guy from the reigning Monster Energy Series champ the rest of the season?
NASCAR.com’s Jonathan Merryman and George Winkler debate whether it’s high time for Truex to change his racing style and demeanor.
MERRYMAN: This past weekend we raced at one of the oldest and prestigious short tracks in the United States, known for producing hard-nosed competition. It was located in Martinsville, Virginia, not Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood.
Some of the biggest houses on the “short-track block” are owned by guys with the last names of Earnhardt, Gordon and Busch — three drivers you most certainly don’t want in your rearview mirror going into Turn 3 at Martinsville, Richmond or Bristol.
Martin Truex Jr. is a nice guy and a very clean race car driver. He also has a zero in the short-track win column. I believe there is a direct correlation between the two.
There is a reason Dale Earnhardt had 20 short-track wins at the Cup level at the three tracks mentioned, Jeff Gordon earned 16 and Kyle Busch — who is far from done — has 15 to his name.
I don’t think Truex Jr. will ever get to the point of retaliation, but it’s time for him to start using the chrome horn if he wants to finally get that coveted short-track win. After all, we call them bumpers for a reason.
WINKLER: What’s more important: Getting that first short-track win, or winning a second championship? I’d vote for the latter because when it’s all said and done, fans are going to remember how many titles Truex won over whether he was a short-track tough guy.
Despite getting bumped out of the way at Martinsville, Truex is right where he needs to be — 25 points above the playoff cutline with another shot at a championship well within his sights. This is not the time to lose your mind and try to get revenge.
Furthermore, there aren’t any beating-and-banging short tracks left on the schedule, so why worry about changing your style? Sure, Phoenix is 1 mile, but it doesn’t race like a true short track. Truex should focus on getting his 1.5-mile program back to where it was in 2017 and dominate at Texas and Homestead and carry home another big trophy.
If Truex keeps his cool, he will show yet again that nice guys can finish first.