RELATED: Full coverage of JGR changes
NASCAR Hall of Fame discussion and debate is typically expected and generally prevalent as talented and high-profile drivers step away from competition. And such is the natural consideration for Carl Edwards, who announced — quite unexpectedly — Wednesday that he was stepping away from competing in the sport.
Edwards, at only age 37, joins former NASCAR multi-time champions Jeff Gordon, 45, and Tony Stewart, 45, in making this career decision in just the last two years. The four-time champion Gordon ended his full-time career in 2015 only to fill-in for injured Hendrick Motorsports teammate Dale Earnhardt Jr. in eight races last season. Stewart, a three-time champ, stepped away from the NASCAR driver’s seat at the end of 2016, but is still competing in other forms of racing.
For both Gordon, a 93-time winner in NASCAR’s premier series and Stewart, a 49-race winner in what is now the Monster Energy NASCAR Cup Series, Hall of Fame induction seems to be a given.
As a contemporary of the two, Edwards’ credentials also will naturally give rise to Hall of Fame discussion even though he competed 12 fewer years than Gordon at the top level and five fewer years than Stewart, an IndyCar champion before he arrived in NASCAR.
CAIN: Edwards exits with focused, sincere class
"I would say that his career, he’ll probably come under strong consideration for everything he did," Edwards team owner Joe Gibbs said of Hall of Fame talk Wednesday following Edwards’ news conference.
Edwards’ NASCAR statistics — highlighted by 28 Cup wins, the 2007 XFINITY Series title to with 38 wins in that series as well as six Camping World Truck Series victories — are certainly impressive even though they don’t include a championship at the Cup level or a Daytona 500 victory.
Three times Edwards came painstakingly close to hoisting the Cup trophy.
He won a season-high nine races in 2008 only to finish runner-up to seven-time winner Jimmie Johnson, who was right in the middle of a five-year championship run.
RELATED: All of Edwards’ wins | Carl in his own words
Edwards was a season runner-up again in 2011, actually tying Stewart in the points standings for the title but losing on a tie-breaker. Stewart won five of the 10 Chase races, Edwards had only one victory on the year. It remains, obviously, the tightest championship battle in NASCAR history.
And of course, Edwards was leading the final race at Homestead-Miami Speedway in November, poised to perhaps at last claim that oh-so elusive championship. But contact with fellow Championship 4 driver Joey Logano with what turned out to be 12 laps remaining, led to a wreck and a fourth-place finish in the standings.
"It’s ironic for him that in the two championship bids that he was right there, one of them he lost by one point and the other one, 15 laps to go and he had it, he was pulling away from everybody," Gibbs said. "I think that it’s not my place to judge all that, but I think those guys will give strong consideration for him in the future."
Since Edwards began full-time premier series competition in 2005, only the newly-crowned seven-time champion Johnson has bettered Edwards’ nine race wins in a single season (2008). Gordon had a string of double digit wins in 1996 (10), 1997 (10) and 1998 (13).
In 2015 Edwards won two of the series’ most iconic races, Charlotte’s Coca-Cola 600 and Darlington Raceway‘s Bojangles’ Southern 500.
He’s won races at 14 tracks on the Cup circuit and proven himself among the most diverse with multiple victories on short tracks like Bristol, intermediate venues such as Texas and has a win on the Sonoma road course.
MORE: Edwards’ decision caught Kenseth by surprise
There is also immediate precedent that Hall of Fame nominees don’t necessarily need a Daytona 500 trophy or a championship ring.
Mark Martin, who will be inducted in NASCAR’s great Hall later this month, earned 40 Cup victories but none came in the Daytona 500, nor did he win a Cup title. One of Martin’s Daytona near-misses, however, is legendary as he came painfully close in 2007 finishing runner-up to Kevin Harvick in a photo finish. He was a five-time runner-up in the Cup series championship. His 40 wins came in 882 starts, compared to Edwards’ 28 wins in 445 starts.
Fred Lorenzen, a 2015 Hall of Fame inductee, won fewer races than Edwards (26) — the 1965 Daytona 500 among them.
Both Edwards and Martin had similar good fortune in the XFINITY Series. Edwards earned 27 pole positions and won 38 times in 245 starts; Martin had 30 poles and won 49 times in 236 starts. Edwards won the 2007 championship and finished runner-up four times — all while running full time in the Cup ranks too. He finished in the top-10 in 174 of those 245 starts — an incredible 71 percent of the time.
And for all of this, Edwards may be a viable Hall of Fame candidate. And he has left the door open to competing in the future. The one thing that is certain, is whether or not Edwards ends up in the Great Hall, he stepped away this week feeling absolutely fulfilled.
"It’s more than I ever expected," Edwards said. "I’ve accomplished more than I ever dreamed of accomplishing. I have the satisfaction that I don’t know how to express.
MORE: Top quotes from Edwards’ news
"Everybody has worked hard at something and been nervous and insecure but kept digging and leaned all those lessons to get to a point, where you’re like, ‘I’ve done this.’
"This is way more than I ever expected. So yeah, I’m very satisfied with that."



